Sorry about the post spam but I am just so excited while listening to this episode!
How did no one mention that Spooky had a podcast that recorded all of adventures in New York!!! It was called Spooky in the City!
There is still a MySpace page for it and Chemda is the only profile on the top 8:
https://myspace.com/spookyinthecity
Look, I had the t-shirt: