The AV Club has been reviewing podcasts regularly for a few months now in their "Podmass" column.
Mostly they tend to skew toward the charmingly incestuous and relatively new world of comedy celebrity-driven LA podcasting but this week they featured KATG, saying, among other things, that "like its West Coast podcast brethren, Keith And The Girl has the feel of a prototype standup routine, but unlike newer West Coast podcasts, it has more than 1,500 episodes of experience that makes for a tighter, smarter, and to some degree, less pretentious show."
Week of March 1-7 | Comedy | Podmass | The A.V. Club
If you're looking for something to do sign up over there and thank them in the comments section. And like Keith
always says, "be nice." They certainly were.