3207: Plot Holes w/ Shelton Lindsay

[Scorpion]

Alright so FM is clearly delusional and we have known that, right.
However, how he can be so delusional to not see what is happening after the “I’d bang him stupid!” I, I... I just don’t know. I don’t get it, how could he... I mean WTF? I believe it, I just can’t believe it!

[Enunciated Piffle]

Originally Posted by Keith

Expectations vs. Finished product

He hoped to get a return on his investment vs. He didn’t

Oh. Totally.

I do think it’d be interesting to hear this investor talk about it though. Did FM impress him initially? What’s his feelings now? Any idea of how many units actually sold? All that.

Maybe once the saga of No Cat is finished, you and Chemda do a phone interview with this guy? Or meh?

[memecherry]

Originally Posted by Keith

Expectations vs. Finished product

He hoped to get a return on his investment vs. He didn’t

When you order it online vs when you get it...

[shoebootie]

Keith should do his stand-up in April as his drag persona Cat Fisher.

[FingerLakes]

Originally Posted by shoebootie

Keith should do his stand-up in April as his drag persona Cat Fisher.

Can you fucking imagine?
Chemda would be the MC: "Thanks everyone for coming to Keith's once a year show. Before we begin here's some background, reach under your chair to find a pen and paper, you'll need to take notes. So, 12 months ago Keith's dad, we call him Father Malley, contacted Keith's wife of THREE YEARS but she told Keith and he started emailing as Cat but we call him Not!Cat..."

[10 minutes of explaining later]
"And now Keith will be doing stand up but only address him as his dragsona, Cat Fischer!"


Jesus Christ. I just got so excited. Can I pre-pay for a VIP pass to this?

[PippaMags]

Dad emails t-shirts keep writing themselves:

“Behave”

???

“Unabridged: Free Bonus Material”

“Tomato Soup”

[PippaMags]

I think Keith’s dad is devastated Bc he needs notCat to be realCat and we are witnessing his brain processing this realization. And I also agree with Keith’s expectation that there won’t be “closure” but rather a discouragement to future emailing / interference with Kyle’s kids. Considering how malicious Keith’s dad is it seems this is the only way to handle this. Well done, Keith! Also I love Chemda so much, the check in with a , “how are you doing buddy?” are super important. Keith is figuratively an orphan with socially inflicted son obligations to two people who are not able to be parents. His mom in mental decline and his dad just completely inept to be a dad.

Love you guys and thank you for sharing this stuff - as wild as it is I also think it is relatable to almost everyone on some level.

[juliofromny]

Has anybody suggested that maybe the next Cat email should have a photo of Keith holding one of their email correspondences (proof life pose) and in all caps behave!!!

And then Keith emails his dad:
a) same photo or
b) a second photo looking at the email sternly or with the thinking 🤔/ scowling 🤨 expression

Maybe increase the font of the printout so it’s easy to tell it’s one of the emails.

Maybe use the email with “makes my libido jingle” quote bolded and underlined (in extra big font so it can be clearly read).